I thought REsident Evil 4 wasn't really that scary.
But, I put my lights off, max volume, was home alone, and was like 2 AM. So, I started up REsident evil 4 on my wii, and I'm apparently near the ending. DAMN, when the mutants who die hard as shit come with those scary sounds and you shoot them, you'll get the chills. And when you blow them up, holy ass.